• Follow us

Social Media

Facebook still a great place to amplify pre-election junk news, EU study finds – TechCrunch

A study carried out by academics at Oxford University to investigate how junk news is being shared on social media in Europe ahead of regional elections this month has found individual stories shared on Facebook’s platform can still hugely outperform the most important and professionally produced news stories, drawing as much as 4x the volume of Facebook shares, likes, and comments.

The study, conducted for the Oxford Internet Institute’s (OII) Computational Propaganda Project, is intended to respond to widespread concern about the spread of online political disinformation on EU elections which take place later this month, by examining pre-election chatter on Facebook and Twitter in English, French, German, Italian, Polish, Spanish, and Swedish.

Junk news in this context refers to content produced by known sources of political misinformation — aka outlets that are systematically producing and spreading “ideologically extreme, misleading, and factually incorrect information” — with the researchers comparing interactions with junk stories from such outlets to news stories produced by the most popular professional news sources to get a snapshot of public engagement with sources of misinformation ahead of the EU vote.

As we reported last year, the Institute also launched a junk news aggregator ahead of the US midterms to help Internet users get a handle on manipulative politically-charged content that might be hitting their feeds.

In the EU the European Commission has responded to rising concern about the impact of online disinformation on democratic processes by stepping up pressure on platforms and the adtech industry — issuing monthly progress reports since January after the introduction of a voluntary code of practice last year intended to encourage action to squeeze the spread of manipulative fakes. Albeit, so far these ‘progress’ reports have mostly boiled down to calls for less foot-dragging and more action.

One tangible result last month was Twitter introducing a report option for misleading tweets related to voting ahead of the EU vote, though again you have to wonder what took it so long given that online election interference is hardly a new revelation. (The OII study is also just the latest piece of research to bolster the age old maxim that falsehoods fly and the truth comes limping after.)

The study also examined how junk news spread on Twitter during the pre-EU election period, with the researchers finding that less than 4% of sources circulating on Twitter’s platform were junk news (or “known Russian sources”) — with Twitter users sharing far more links to mainstream news outlets overall (34%) over the study period.

Although the Polish language sphere was an exception — with junk news making up a fifth (21%) of EU election-related Twitter traffic in that outlying case.

Returning to Facebook, while the researchers do note that many more users interact with mainstream content overall via its platform, noting that mainstream publishers have a higher following and so “wider access to drive activity around their content” and meaning their stories “tend to be seen, liked, and shared by far more users overall”, they also point out that junk news still packs a greater per story punch — likely owing to the use of tactics such as clickbait, emotive language, and outragemongering in headlines which continues to be shown to generate more clicks and engagement on social media.

It’s also of course much quicker and easier to make some shit up vs the slower pace of doing rigorous professional journalism — so junk news purveyors can get out ahead of news events also as an eyeball-grabbing strategy to further the spread of their cynical BS. (And indeed the researchers go on to say that most of the junk news sources being shared during the pre-election period “either sensationalized or spun political and social events covered by mainstream media sources to serve a political and ideological agenda”.)

“While junk news sites were less prolific publishers than professional news producers, their stories tend to be much more engaging,” they write in a data memo covering the study. “Indeed, in five out of the seven languages (English, French, German, Spanish, and Swedish), individual stories from popular junk news outlets received on average between 1.2 to 4 times as many likes, comments, and shares than stories from professional media sources.

“In the German sphere, for instance, interactions with mainstream stories averaged only 315 (the lowest across this sub-sample) while nearing 1,973 for equivalent junk news stories.”

To conduct the research the academics gathered more than 584,000 tweets related to the European parliamentary elections from more than 187,000 unique users between April 5 and April 20 using election-related hashtags — from which they extracted more than 137,000 tweets containing a URL link, which pointed to a total of 5,774 unique media sources.

Sources that were shared 5x or more across the collection period were manually classified by a team of nine multi-lingual coders based on what they describe as “a rigorous grounded typology developed and refined through the project’s previous studies of eight elections in several countries around the world”.

Each media source was coded individually by two separate coders, via which technique they say was able to successfully label nearly 91% of all links shared during the study period. 

The five most popular junk news sources were extracted from each language sphere looked at — with the researchers then measuring the volume of Facebook interactions with these outlets between April 5 and May 5, using the NewsWhip Analytics dashboard.

They also conducted a thematic analysis of the 20 most engaging junk news stories on Facebook during the data collection period to gain a better understanding of the different political narratives favoured by junk news outlets ahead of an election.

On the latter front they say the most engaging junk narratives over the study period “tend to revolve around populist themes such as anti-immigration and Islamophobic sentiment, with few expressing Euroscepticism or directly mentioning European leaders or parties”.

Which suggests that EU-level political disinformation is a more issue-focused animal (and/or less developed) — vs the kind of personal attacks that have been normalized in US politics (and were richly and infamously exploited by Kremlin-backed anti-Clinton political disinformation during the 2016 US presidential election, for example).

This is likely also because of a lower level of political awareness attached to individuals involved in EU institutions and politics, and the multi-national state nature of the pan-EU project — which inevitably bakes in far greater diversity. (We can posit that just as it aids robustness in biological life, diversity appears to bolster democratic resilience vs political nonsense.)

The researchers also say they identified two noticeable patterns in the thematic content of junk stories that sought to cynically spin political or social news events for political gain over the pre-election study period.

“Out of the twenty stories we analysed, 9 featured explicit mentions of ‘Muslims’ and the Islamic faith in general, while seven mentioned ‘migrants’, ‘immigration’, or ‘refugees’… In seven instances, mentions of Muslims and immigrants were coupled with reporting on terrorism or violent crime, including sexual assault and honour killings,” they write.

“Several stories also mentioned the Notre Dame fire, some propagating the idea that the arson had been deliberately plotted by Islamist terrorists, for example, or suggesting that the French government’s reconstruction plans for the cathedral would include a minaret. In contrast, only 4 stories featured Euroscepticism or direct mention of European Union leaders and parties.

“The ones that did either turned a specific political figure into one of derision – such as Arnoud van Doorn, former member of PVV, the Dutch nationalist and far-right party of Geert Wilders, who converted to Islam in 2012 – or revolved around domestic politics. One such story relayed allegations that Emmanuel Macron had been using public taxes to finance ISIS jihadists in Syrian camps, while another highlighted an offer by Vladimir Putin to provide financial assistance to rebuild Notre Dame.”

Taken together, the researchers conclude that “individuals discussing politics on social media ahead of the European parliamentary elections shared links to high-quality news content, including high volumes of content produced by independent citizen, civic groups and civil society organizations, compared to other elections we monitored in France, Sweden, and Germany”.

Which suggests that attempts to manipulate the pan-EU election are either less prolific or, well, less successful than those which have targeted some recent national elections in EU Member States. And logic would suggest that co-ordinating election interference across a 28-Member State bloc does require greater co-ordination and resource vs trying to meddle in a single national election — on account of the multiple countries, cultures, languages and issues involved.

We’ve reached out to Facebook for comment on the study’s findings. Update: A company spokesperson has now sent the following statement:

We’ve been working hard to stop the spread of false news. Actors seeking to profit from misinformation are highly motivated and continue to employ new tactics to garner clicks, so it’s possible to pick out specific examples of things we miss and there will occasionally be false news posts that perform well–but what we’re really interested in is the overall amount of misinformation on Facebook, and whether that’s trending down. By Oxford’s own admission, overall, mainstream media coverage of the EU elections performed better than “junk news” on Facebook, both in terms of publisher following and engagement.

The company has put a heavy focus on publicizing its self-styled ‘election security’ efforts ahead of the EU election. Though it has mostly focused on setting up systems to control political ads — whereas junk news purveyors are simply uploading regular Facebook ‘content’ at the same time as wrapping it in bogus claims of ‘journalism’ — none of which Facebook objects to. All of which allows would-be election manipulators to pass off junk views as online news, leveraging the reach of Facebook’s platform and its attention-hogging algorithms to amplify hateful nonsense. While any increase in engagement is a win for Facebook’s ad business, so er…

Read More



Leave A Comment

More News

TechCrunch » Social

Facebook still a great place to amplify pre-election 2019-05-21 07:34:54A study carried out by academics at Oxford University to investigate how junk news is being shared on social media in Europe ahead of regional electio

Snap appoints new execs as it aims to 2019-05-20 19:15:14Snap has another appointment in the apt saga of its ephemeral CFOs. Four months after losing its CFO Tim Stone following a reported “personality

Maisie Williams’ talent discovery startup Daisie raises $2.5 2019-05-20 16:17:57Maisie Williams’ time on Game of Thrones may have come to an end, but her talent discovery app Daisie is just getting started. Co-founded by fil

Why is Facebook doing robotics research? 2019-05-20 16:06:41It's a bit strange to hear that the world's leading social network is pursuing research in robotics rather than, say, making search useful, but Face

Instagram’s IGTV copies TikTok’s AI, Snapchat’s design 2019-05-20 15:49:40Instagram conquered Stories, but it’s losing the battle for the next video formats. TikTok is blowing up with an algorithmically suggested verti

On the Internet of Women with Moira Weigel 2019-05-20 12:15:26“Feminism,” the writer and editor Marie Shear famously said in an often-misattributed quote, “is the radical notion that women are p

TikTok owner ByteDance’s long-awaited chat app is here 2019-05-19 22:49:55In WeChat -dominated China, there’s no shortage of challengers out there claiming to create an alternative social experience. The latest creatio

Facebook changes algorithm to promote worthwhile & close 2019-05-16 11:14:04Facebook is updating the News Feed ranking algorithm to incorporate data from surveys about who you say are your closest friends and which links you f

Instagram adds Stories to Explore tab. Here’s how 2019-05-16 09:59:47Instagram’s pivot to Stories continues with an overhaul of Explore designed to let users dig deeper into their niche interests. Stories are now

Instagram is killing Direct, its standalone Snapchat clone 2019-05-16 07:09:53As Facebook pushes ahead with its strategy to consolidate more of the backend of its various apps on to a single platform, it’s also doing a lit

Facebook introduces ‘one strike’ policy to combat abuse 2019-05-15 02:09:27Facebook is cracking down on its live-streaming service after it was used to broadcast the shocking mass shootings that left 50 dead at two Christchur

Twitter launches new search features to stop the 2019-05-14 23:05:26As measles outbreaks in the United States and other countries continue to get worse, Twitter is introducing new search tools meant to help users find

Mashable

Watch these brave humans risk everything to chase 2019-05-28 11:43:23Some people will do anything to get cheese, no matter the cost. Contestants at the annual Gloucestershire cheese rolling festival risked injuries as t

'Super Mario 2' hands-on: What a delight 2019-05-28 11:39:39Super Mario Maker 2 is so much fun. I only played about an hour of Super Mario Maker 2 for the Nintendo Switch at a preview event, jumping between the

Save $70 on a Dell 24-inch monitor *and* 2019-05-28 11:34:01Your computer monitor can really make or break your work experience. If you have a shitty monitor it can be difficult to focus or your work might take

Tesla raced one car above ground versus another 2019-05-28 11:32:38Elon Musk’s idea for underground travel in California was tested recently by racing two Tesla cars; one through normal traffic, and the other th

Snag the Samsung Galaxy Tab A on sale 2019-05-28 11:18:05Memorial Day weekend marked the unofficial start of beach-read season, which means a new lightweight tablet should be at the top of your "to-buy" li

MacKenzie Bezos pledges to donate half her fortune 2019-05-28 11:13:47MacKenzie Bezos has pledged to give half her estimated $36.6 billion fortune to charity. Her ex-husband hasn't, though! The newly independent billion

Ring’s outdoor smart lighting system is $30 off 2019-05-28 11:12:39You’ve probably heard of smart lighting systems for your home before — the Philips Hue setup is very popular among consumers and smart hom

'Killing Eve' and the TV tightrope of escalating 2019-05-28 11:11:32Warning: The following post contains spoilers for Killing Eve's Season 2 finale. If Eve Polastri's work-life balance was complicated before, she's

Amazon Fire TV devices are up to $100 2019-05-28 11:07:59Arguably one of the most annoying parts about watching TV is losing the remote. It can have you flipping over couch cushions and losing all trust in y

Viral 'Egg Boy' announces he's donated his GoFundMe 2019-05-28 11:00:05Once again, Australia's "Egg Boy" has proven to be not the hero we deserve, but the one we need. Will Connolly, you may recall, is the teenager who

Netgear Orbi, Sandisk SD Cards, Western Digital Hard 2019-05-28 10:57:43First day back to work after a long weekend is never easy. What better to ease the pain than with some online retail therapyAmazon deals of the day ga

Weatherman goes off after 'Bachelorette' fans complain about 2019-05-28 10:35:55Will you accept this rose? No? Well, we hope you can at least accept this urgent safety interruption. Fans on the edge of their seat during Monday nig

The Next Web

IOTA wants to ditch its most centralized component, 2019-05-28 11:02:38IOTA, a distributed ledger protocol for the Internet of Things, has released a new white paper detailing an upcoming software upgrade that promises to

Kik raised $98M with a potentially illegal ICO. 2019-05-28 10:30:17Kik, the embattled messaging startup behind the Kin cryptocurrency, is now crowd-sourcing donations to help fund its legal battle with US regulat

Facebook is so insanely big, it had to 2019-05-28 10:21:41You can tell a lot about the direction of a company by looking at its tech stack. A great example of this comes from Facebook, which today announced t

Apple updates iPod Touch with A10 fusion chip 2019-05-28 09:21:45Apple today released a new iPod Touch with A10 fusion chip that supports group FaceTime chats and improved augmented reality capabilities. The rest of

Catalyze your data science education with this $20 2019-05-28 09:00:00Over six courses packed with 130 hours of training, this is where to start understanding today’s data revolution. From key programming disciplin

Nvidia adds ray-tracing support to Quake 2 with 2019-05-28 08:58:26Now this brings me back. Remember Quake 2? This iconic first-person shooter was released towards the tail-end of the 1990’s, and boasted fast-pa

This website turns Bitcoin blockchain activity into ASMR 2019-05-28 08:19:50Holding cryptocurrency can be exhilarating, yet absolutely depressing. Luckily, a website automatically transmogrifies Bitcoin activity into soft

CHEAP: Project your true feelings with 33% off 2019-05-28 08:00:20Love hosting movie nights? Want to watch a game with your friends, but don’t have a big-screen TV? Then hop on to the deal wagon and grab this&n

This super-slim laptop stand raised over $1 million 2019-05-28 08:00:00The solution to the solution is the MOFT, or, as it’s better known, the “invisible” laptop stand. Right now, you can get the MOFT an

HP’s Envy laptops get a sexy new wood 2019-05-28 07:32:06It’s interesting to see the continuing evolution of HP’s laptop division into a more premium, aspirational brand. That shift is typified b

Google stored some G Suite passwords in plaintext 2019-05-22 04:33:12Google revealed that it recently discovered a bug that caused a subset of its enterprise G Suite customers to have their passwords stored in an unhash

The privacy-focused Tor browser is now officially on 2019-05-22 04:28:57After a long wait, privacy-focused browser Tor is finally on Android with a stable release. Last September, the Tor project team launched an alph

Entrepreneur

Death by Investing: How a 10 Percent Loss 2019-05-28 11:30:00Stock market declines are linked to early death, illness, and fatal accidents. Are you at risk?

12 Ways That Writers, Speakers and Experts Can 2019-05-28 11:19:58Information and inspiration are valuable commodities in the entrepreneurial world.

10 User Experience Design Trends You Need to 2019-05-28 11:00:00You might already know about augmented reality, but do you know about foldable phones and three-dimensional design?

Apple Launches a New iPod Touch 2019-05-28 10:58:21It's been nearly four years since the 6th generation iPod touch was released, but today Apple upgraded it with an A10 Fusion chip, augmented reality,

Why Entrepreneurship Alone Isn't Enough To Make You 2019-05-28 10:30:00You can't just be savvy about your business strategy. Keep these steps in mind to make your money work for you.

3 Ways That Even 'Nonhuman' AI Can Help 2019-05-28 10:30:00How about immediate customer feedback, efficient customer support and personalization?

Laptop Full of Malware Sells for $1.3 Million 2019-05-28 10:24:19It's an art piece containing six pieces of malware responsible for $95 billion worth of damage, and it just sold at auction for $1.345 million.

6 Tips for Starting a Business That's an 2019-05-28 09:30:00Looking to start a business that resonates with locals? Take a cue from Proper Hospitality co-founder Brian De Lowe, who makes sure each of his new ho

'If You Don't Stand for Something, You Seem 2019-05-28 09:00:00Marshall Rader and his brother encountered plenty of naysayers for their business. They proved them wrong.

Greg Flynn Owns 1,245 Restaurants and Makes $2 2019-05-28 09:00:00He bought his first Applebee's 20 years ago, and since then has redefined what's possible in the franchise industry. His philosophy: Be different, t

Mergers May Mean More Money, but You Can't 2019-05-28 08:00:00You may be tempted by that flashy merger deal, but here are a few reasons you should think twice before diving in.

Most States Provide No Legal Protection If You're 2019-05-28 08:00:00There are 33 states where medical marijuana is legal but only 13 where you have recourse if you're fired for it.

E-Commerce Times

Leveraging the Tools That Fuel E-Commerce Growth 2019-05-25 08:00:00E-commerce technologies have been innovating fast. It's no surprise, considering e-commerce in North America grew by 15 percent in 2018, to reach mor

Where CEOs Go Wrong With Brand ID 2019-05-24 12:10:52Brand ID is key to every company's success and growth. Why then do so many senior executives at so many different companies screw it up? When you com

ARM Joins Firms Shunning Huawei's Business 2019-05-23 05:41:59British mobile device software design firm ARM has ordered its staff to stop working with Chinese smartphone giant Huawei, in compliance with a ban is

Better Customer Satisfaction Through AI-Enabled CRM 2019-05-22 10:00:00You don't have to be entrenched in the tech world to have heard the term, "artificial intelligence," but what is artificial intelligence, or AI, a

EU's Counterattack on Junk News May Help Protect 2019-05-22 05:56:48Government efforts to minimize the effects of junk and fake news circulating on social media ahead of this week's EU parliamentary elections may have

Cybercriminals Score Billions in Cryptocurrency Thefts 2019-05-21 13:05:56Is anyone surprised to learn that in just the first quarter of 2019 more than $1.2 billion worth of cryptocurrency was stolen? Probably not. This stor

5 Effective Talent Retention Strategies for Security Teams 2019-05-20 15:39:41In IT, we've been hearing about the "cybersecurity skills shortage" for a few years. There is no shortage of statistics and data about it: More tha

Omnichannel Retail: Big Data Is Nice, Fast Data 2019-05-18 08:00:00Any retailer that wants to be competitive knows it must offer a seamless omnichannel experience to its customers. However, many retailers aren't awar

US Mobile: Another Bait-and-Switch Disappointment 2019-05-16 08:00:00I just dumped US Mobile after less than four months, setting a new speed record for hitting my tolerance-for-b.s. ceiling. I'd had high hopes for thi

Walmart Enters High-Stakes Next-Day Delivery Game 2019-05-15 13:11:29Walmart has announced free one-day delivery for 220,000 of its most-frequently purchased items. The service will be available first in Phoenix and Las

Technology Is Filling a Need in Philanthropy 2019-05-14 15:30:17It's surprising that philanthropy as an industry has gotten by for so long without technology. That's changing, however. The cost of technology has

Flexa Launches Crypto-Based Payment App 2019-05-14 12:55:54Flexa has launched a new digital payment network that uses cryptocurrencies to cut processing costs, eliminate fraud and preserve users' privacy. The


Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.