• Follow us

Social Media

Friend portability is the must-have Facebook regulation – TechCrunch

Choice for consumers compels fair treatment by corporations. When people can easily move to a competitor, it creates a natural market dynamic coercing a business to act right. When we can’t, other regulations just leave us trapped with a pig in a fresh coat of lipstick.

That’s why as the FTC considers how many billions to fine Facebook or which executives to stick with personal liability or whether to go full-tilt and break up the company, I implore it to consider the root of how Facebook gets away with abusing user privacy: there’s no simple way to switch to an alternative.

If Facebook users are fed up with the surveillance, security breaches, false news or hatred, there’s no western general-purpose social network with scale for them to join. Twitter is for short-form public content. Snapchat is for ephemeral communication. Tumblr is neglected. Google+ is dead. Instagram is owned by Facebook. And the rest are either Chinese, single-purpose or tiny.

No, I don’t expect the FTC to launch its own “Fedbook” social network. But what it can do is pave an escape route from Facebook so worthy alternatives become viable options. That’s why the FTC must require Facebook to offer truly interoperable data portability for the social graph.

In other words, the government should pass regulations forcing Facebook to let you export your friend list to other social networks in a privacy-safe way. This would allow you to connect with or follow those people elsewhere so you could leave Facebook without losing touch with your friends. The increased threat of people ditching Facebook for competitors would create a much stronger incentive to protect users and society.

The slate of potential regulations for Facebook currently being discussed by the FTC’s heads include a $3 billion to $5 billion fine or greater, holding Facebook’s CEO personally liable for violations of an FTC consent decree, creating new privacy and compliance positions (including one held by an executive that could be filled by Zuckerberg) and creating an independent oversight committee to review privacy and product decisions, according to The New York Times and The Washington Post. More extreme measures like restricting how Facebook collects and uses data for ad targeting, blocking future acquisitions or breaking up the company are still possible, but seemingly less likely.

Facebook co-founder Chris Hughes (right) recently wrote a scathing call to break up Facebook

Breaking apart Facebook is a tantalizing punishment for the company’s wrongdoings. Still, I somewhat agree with Zuckerberg’s response to co-founder Chris Hughes’ call to split up the company, which he said “isn’t going to do anything to help” directly fix Facebook’s privacy or misinformation issues. Given Facebook likely wouldn’t try to make more acquisitions of big social networks under all this scrutiny, it’d benefit from voluntarily pledging not to attempt these buys for at least three to five years. Otherwise, regulators could impose that ban, which might be more politically attainable with fewer messy downstream effects.

Yet without this data portability regulation, Facebook can pay a fine and go back to business as usual. It can accept additional privacy oversight without fundamentally changing its product. It can become liable for upholding the bare minimum letter of the law while still breaking the spirit. And even if it was broken up, users still couldn’t switch from Facebook to Instagram, or from Instagram and WhatsApp to somewhere new.

Facebook kills competition with user lock-in

When faced with competition in the past, Facebook has snapped into action improving itself. Fearing Google+ in 2011, Zuckerberg vowed “Carthage must be destroyed” and the company scrambled to launch Messenger, the Timeline profile, Graph Search, photo improvements and more. After realizing the importance of mobile in 2012, Facebook redesigned its app, reorganized its teams and demanded employees carry Android phones for “dogfooding” testing. And when Snapchat was still rapidly growing into a rival, Facebook cloned its Stories and is now adopting the philosophy of ephemerality.

Mark Zuckerberg visualizes his social graph at a Facebook conference

Each time Facebook felt threatened, it was spurred to improve its product for consumers. But once it defeated its competitors, muted their growth or confined them to a niche purpose, Facebook’s privacy policies worsened. Anti-trust scholar Dina Srinivasan explains this in her summary of her paper “The Anti-Trust Case Against Facebook”:

When dozens of companies competed in an attempt to win market share, and all competing products were priced at zero—privacy quickly emerged as a key differentiator. When Facebook entered the market it specifically promised users: “We do not and will not use cookies to collect private information from any user.” Competition didn’t only restrain Facebook’s ability to track users. It restrained every social network from trying to engage in this behavior . . .  the exit of competition greenlit a change in conduct by the sole surviving firm. By early 2014, dozens of rivals that initially competed with Facebook had effectively exited the market. In June of 2014, rival Google announced it would shut down its competitive social network, ceding the social network market to Facebook.

For Facebook, the network effects of more than a billion users on a closed-communications protocol further locked in the market in its favor. These circumstances—the exit of competition and the lock-in of consumers—finally allowed Facebook to get consumers to agree to something they had resisted from the beginning. Almost simultaneous with Google’s exit, Facebook announced (also in June of 2014) that it would begin to track users’ behavior on websites and apps across the Internet and use the data gleaned from such surveillance to target and influence consumers. Shortly thereafter, it started tracking non-users too. It uses the “like” buttons and other software licenses to do so.

This is why the FTC must seek regulation that not only punishes Facebook for wrongdoings, but that lets consumers do the same. Users can punch holes in Facebook by leaving, both depriving it of ad revenue and reducing its network effect for others. Empowering them with the ability to take their friend list with them gives users a taller seat at the table. I’m calling for what University of Chicago professors Luigi Zingales and Guy Rolnik termed a Social Data Portability Act.

Luckily, Facebook already has a framework for this data portability through a feature called Find Friends. You connect your Facebook account to another app, and you can find your Facebook friends who are already on that app.

But the problem is that in the past, Facebook has repeatedly blocked competitors from using Find Friends. That includes cutting off Twitter, Vine, Voxer and MessageMe, while Phhhoto was blocked from letting you find your Instagram friends…six months before Instagram copied Phhhoto’s core back-and-forth GIF feature and named it Boomerang. Then there’s the issue that you need an active Facebook account to use Find Friends. That nullifies its utility as a way to bring your social graph with you when you leave Facebook.

Facebook’s “Find Friends” feature used to let Twitter users follow their Facebook friends, but Facebook later cut off access for competitors, including Twitter and Vine, seen here

The social network does offer a way to “Download Your Information,” which is helpful for exporting photos, status updates, messages and other data about you. Yet the friend list can only be exported as a text list of names in HTML or JSON format. Names aren’t linked to their corresponding Facebook profiles or any unique identifier, so there’s no way to find your friend John Smith amongst everyone with that name on another app. And less than 5% of my 2,800 connections had used the little-known option to allow friends to export their email address. What about the big “Data Transfer Project” Facebook announced 10 months ago in partnership with Google, Twitter and Microsoft to provide more portability? It’s released nothing so far, raising questions of whether it was vaporware designed to ward off regulators.

Essentially, this all means that Facebook provides zero portability for your friendships. That’s what regulators need to change. There’s already precedent for this. The Telecommunications Act of 1996 saw the FCC require phone service carriers to allow customers to easily port their numbers to another carrier rather than having to be assigned a new number. If you think of a phone number as a method by which friends connect with you, it would be reasonable for regulators to declare that the modern equivalent — your social network friend connections — must be similarly portable.

How to unchain our friendships

Facebook should be required to let you export a truly interoperable friend list that can be imported into other apps in a privacy-safe way.

To do that, Facebook should allow you to download a version of the list that features hashed versions of the phone numbers and email addresses friends used to sign up. You wouldn’t be able to read that contact info or freely import and spam people. But Facebook could be required to share documentation teaching developers of other apps to build a feature that safely cross-checks the hashed numbers and email addresses against those of people who had signed up for their app. That developer wouldn’t be able to read the contact info from Facebook either, or store any useful data about people who hadn’t signed up for their app. But if the phone number or email address of someone in your exported Facebook friend list matched one of their users, they could offer to let you connect with or follow them.

This system would let you save your social graph, delete your Facebook account, and then find your friends on other apps without ever jeopardizing the privacy of their contact info. Users would no longer be locked into Facebook and could freely choose to move their friendships to whatever social network treats them best. And Facebook wouldn’t be able to block competitors from using it.

If the company wanted to go a step further, it could offer ways to makes News Feed content preferences or Facebook Groups connections portable, such as by making it easier for Group members to opt-in to joining a parallel email or text message mailing list. For researchers, Facebook could offer ways to export anonymized News Feed and activity data for study.

Portability would much more closely align the goals of users, Facebook and the regulators. Facebook wouldn’t merely be responsible to the government for technically complying with new fines, oversight or liability. It would finally have to compete to provide the best social app rather than relying on its network effect to handcuff users to its service.

This same model of data portability regulation could be expanded to any app with more than 1 billion users, or even 100 million users to ensure YouTube, Twitter, Snapchat or Reddit couldn’t lock down users either. By only applying the rule to apps with a sufficiently large user base, the regulation wouldn’t hinder new startup entrants to the market and accidentally create a moat around well-funded incumbents like Facebook that can afford the engineering chore. Data portability regulation combined with a fine, liability, oversight and a ban on future acquisitions of social networks could set Facebook straight without breaking it up.

Users have a lot of complaints about Facebook that go beyond strictly privacy. But their recourse is always limited because for many functions there’s nowhere else to go, and it’s too hard to go there. By fixing the latter, the FTC could stimulate the rise of Facebook alternatives so that users rather regulators can play king-maker.

Read More



Leave A Comment

More News

TechCrunch » Social

Facebook still a great place to amplify pre-election 2019-05-21 07:34:54A study carried out by academics at Oxford University to investigate how junk news is being shared on social media in Europe ahead of regional electio

Snap appoints new execs as it aims to 2019-05-20 19:15:14Snap has another appointment in the apt saga of its ephemeral CFOs. Four months after losing its CFO Tim Stone following a reported “personality

Maisie Williams’ talent discovery startup Daisie raises $2.5 2019-05-20 16:17:57Maisie Williams’ time on Game of Thrones may have come to an end, but her talent discovery app Daisie is just getting started. Co-founded by fil

Why is Facebook doing robotics research? 2019-05-20 16:06:41It's a bit strange to hear that the world's leading social network is pursuing research in robotics rather than, say, making search useful, but Face

Instagram’s IGTV copies TikTok’s AI, Snapchat’s design 2019-05-20 15:49:40Instagram conquered Stories, but it’s losing the battle for the next video formats. TikTok is blowing up with an algorithmically suggested verti

On the Internet of Women with Moira Weigel 2019-05-20 12:15:26“Feminism,” the writer and editor Marie Shear famously said in an often-misattributed quote, “is the radical notion that women are p

TikTok owner ByteDance’s long-awaited chat app is here 2019-05-19 22:49:55In WeChat -dominated China, there’s no shortage of challengers out there claiming to create an alternative social experience. The latest creatio

Facebook changes algorithm to promote worthwhile & close 2019-05-16 11:14:04Facebook is updating the News Feed ranking algorithm to incorporate data from surveys about who you say are your closest friends and which links you f

Instagram adds Stories to Explore tab. Here’s how 2019-05-16 09:59:47Instagram’s pivot to Stories continues with an overhaul of Explore designed to let users dig deeper into their niche interests. Stories are now

Instagram is killing Direct, its standalone Snapchat clone 2019-05-16 07:09:53As Facebook pushes ahead with its strategy to consolidate more of the backend of its various apps on to a single platform, it’s also doing a lit

Facebook introduces ‘one strike’ policy to combat abuse 2019-05-15 02:09:27Facebook is cracking down on its live-streaming service after it was used to broadcast the shocking mass shootings that left 50 dead at two Christchur

Twitter launches new search features to stop the 2019-05-14 23:05:26As measles outbreaks in the United States and other countries continue to get worse, Twitter is introducing new search tools meant to help users find

Mashable

'Game of Thrones' finale defended by 'Seinfeld' star 2019-05-22 00:36:27Game of Thrones is done and dusted, wrapping up its polarising eighth and final season with an equally debated finale. While many have criticised the

Google stored some users' passwords in plain text 2019-05-22 00:29:53Google has revealed it had left some business users' passwords exposed in plain text. In a blog post on Tuesday, the tech giant said it had discovere

Amazon prevails in battle with South American countries 2019-05-21 17:39:12E-commerce giant Amazon has prevailed in its domain name battle with Amazon, the geographic region in South America. The Internet Corporation for Assi

Ben Carson mixed up the real estate term 2019-05-21 17:32:14Can you picture a scenario in which Oreo cookies are discussed at a House Financial Services Committee hearing? No? That's OK. No need to imagine hyp

Dungeons & Dragons Ruined My Life 2019-05-21 17:10:11 Read more...More about Dungeons Dragons, Mashable Reels, Entertainment, and Gaming

Tesla releases DIY guides for Model 3 maintenance 2019-05-21 17:08:02Tesla is embracing the growing demand for consumers to be able to fix stuff themselves by releasing a series of do-it-yourself guides for the Model 3.

Best graduation gifts for him: 50+ gift ideas 2019-05-21 16:29:39Every year, graduation season means a fresh new batch of grads are about to enter full-on adulthood. If you know a guy who is gearing up to walk acros

Kit Harington, Sophie Turner respond to critics of 2019-05-21 16:20:22Game of Thrones actors Kit Harington and Sophie Turner are responding to criticism on the HBO show's ending, defending the hard work the cast and cre

Comcast, a trusted company, wants to monitor you 2019-05-21 16:14:43It looks like you fell down. Someone will be there between 11 a.m. and 5 p.m. to assist you.  Yes, that's right, everyone's favorite and defini

Tesla hires the 'absolute unit' meme guy to 2019-05-21 16:04:01Tesla has reportedly hired Adam Koszary, the man responsible for the "absolute unit" meme, as its new social media manager. Koszary, who used to wor

Plastic water bottle appears in 'Game of Thrones' 2019-05-21 14:41:37Fans spotted a plastic water bottle in the Game of Thrones finale. The bottle's appearance follows that of a Starbucks cup mistakenly left in a shot

This 'Game of Thrones' meme is brilliant and 2019-05-21 14:40:03Warning: The following post contains spoilers for the finale of Game of Thrones.  Game of Thrones may have come to an underwhelming end, but the

The Next Web

Google stored some G Suite passwords in plaintext 2019-05-22 04:33:12Google revealed that it recently discovered a bug that caused a subset of its enterprise G Suite customers to have their passwords stored in an unhash

The privacy-focused Tor browser is now officially on 2019-05-22 04:28:57After a long wait, privacy-focused browser Tor is finally on Android with a stable release. Last September, the Tor project team launched an alph

Tether in court: Yep, we sort of, kind 2019-05-22 04:12:27It appears that contrary to its marketing promises, Tether – a cryptocurrency pegged to the US dollar – used some of its dollar reserves t

Report: Female-sounding voice assistants fuel gender bias 2019-05-21 21:50:49AI-powered voice assistants from Google, Amazon, Apple, and others could be perpetuating harmful gender biases, according to a recent UN report. The r

Microsoft’s Windows 10 May 2019 Update is now 2019-05-21 21:11:20Keeping to its promise of semiannual updates, Microsoft today announced it’s made the next big version of Windows 10 available. The simply-named

This teacher earns six figures teaching Dungeons & 2019-05-21 18:59:45Most people play games like Dungeons & Dragons to get away from their problems. But Megan Hardy isn’t most people. She used it to solve hers

You can build your own Lightsaber and Droid 2019-05-21 17:17:19Disney’s finally lifting the veil on its Star Wars: Galaxy’s Edge attraction set to debut at Disneyland on May 31. And while we were all e

What’s a flagship phone anyway? 2019-05-21 16:55:16Recommending phones used to be easy. A few years ago, if a friend was coming to the end of their contract and needed to pick a new model, I’d te

Sony shows off PS4 Spider-Man game on PS5 2019-05-21 15:39:03We’ve allegedly had our first look at what Sony‘s next-generation PlayStation console will be capable of doing — and, unfortunately,

The future of AI is collaborative 2019-05-21 12:16:28AI is becoming increasingly widespread, affecting all facets of society — even Sonic drive-ins are planning to implement artificial intelligence

The new Honor 20 series has great specs, 2019-05-21 12:10:41It’s a bit of a tough time for Huawei‘s budget sub brand Honor to release its latest flagship phone, but, the show must go on. And, to be

Research reveals surprising relationship between climate change and 2019-05-21 11:04:49Climate change will shape every aspect of human life – often in complex ways. Take the question of deciding how many children to have, for examp

Entrepreneur

Ecommerce Analytics: 4 Metrics That Are Often Overlooked 2019-05-21 12:00:00Are you keeping track of customer lifetime value and customer acquisition cost? It's high time you did.

How to Create Your First Successful Business Plan 2019-05-21 11:30:00Entrepreneurial expert Chris Haroun uses his patented process to help make your new business plan a reality.

Will Your Product Launch Be a Success? 4 2019-05-21 11:00:00The truth is, most product launches fail for two very simple reasons, both of which you've heard about time and time again.

To Break up the Boys' Club, Ladies, Why 2019-05-21 10:30:00Women in VC roles can't rely on public relations fixes, token nods or the chivalry of their male colleagues. They have to do it themselves.

How to Help Other People Be Successful 2019-05-21 10:30:00This CEO breaks down some of the common challenges a business might face in its early stages.

Sony Just Laid Out Everything There Is to 2019-05-21 10:03:14Expect the PlayStation 4 to stick around for at least three more years.

Here's How Rita Moreno's 'Sweatshop Seamstress' Mother Inspired 2019-05-21 09:37:00The screen icon gave kudos to her mom while accepting the Peabody's Career Achievement Award.

Follow These Strategies to Recruit and Retain Employees 2019-05-21 09:30:00Here are three strategies for recruiting and retaining successful employees.

Michelle Pfeiffer's Fragrance Brand Took 20 Years (And 2019-05-21 09:00:00She wanted the fragrance industry to be more transparent.The fragrance industry said no. So the actress took matters into her own hands.

Women Are Disappearing From the Cannabis Industry. Why? 2019-05-21 09:00:00The industry's most powerful women are working to fix it.

The Top Food Franchises of 2019 2019-05-21 09:00:00Food dominates the franchise world. Here, we rank the strongest brands in 14 tasty categories.

Everything You Need To Know To Pitch An 2019-05-21 09:00:00Asking investors to fund your business is uncomfortable, intimidating, and at times even excruciating. Here's how to make it better, according to And

E-Commerce Times

What Happens to Sprint if T-Mobile Merger Fails? 2019-05-09 14:39:27Sprint's best shot at success is to merge with T-Mobile. Without the merger, I see the company continuing to struggle as a weak player in the competi

The Vital Role of Customer Service in the 2019-05-08 14:50:35By 2022, the sharing economy is expected to double, reaching $40 Billion. Pioneers such as Airbnb and Uber are now global titans, taking in billions o

Amazon Touts Small Biz Success on Its Platform 2019-05-08 13:24:56Third-party gross physical merchandise sales on Amazon, made primarily by SMBs, accounted for more than half the units sold in the company's stores a

Einstein Analytics for Financial Services 2019-05-07 14:51:40It's not that Salesforce has introduced more artificial intelligence apps for its Einstein analytics tool set -- this time for financial services --

Spring Cleaning Your Network Security 2019-05-07 13:27:44Spring may be my favorite time of year. The snow is melting, the sun is shining, and the air smells just a little bit fresher. It's as though the wor

4 Advanced Ways Brands Use Data to Increase 2019-05-06 15:18:39Data is one of the biggest advantages e-commerce brands have over their brick-and-mortar counterparts. Brands that sell products online can glean insi

Small Biz Reaps Major Benefits With Oracle Autonomous 2019-05-04 08:00:00Drop Tank is a small company in footprint -- it started with only 22 people -- but it has an outsized mission: to provide loyalty and discount program

What Everyone's Getting Wrong About Digital Transformation 2019-05-03 14:57:40Digital transformation is all the rage right now, and tech companies are working hard to promote it. You can hardly take an action online or go to a c

The Critical Role of Artificial Intelligence in Payments 2019-05-02 15:05:07Long an obsession of science fiction writers, "artificial intelligence" in the modern era of fast-paced technological innovation is a term that is a

AI Raises the Bar for Home Network Security 2019-05-02 13:25:59Consumers are becoming increasingly concerned about the hacking of their devices and data as they hear about more data breaches and have their own exp

New CRM Research Shows Awareness Gap 2019-05-01 16:07:33CRM guru Esteban Kolsky and I did some primary research earlier this year, paid for by Zoho. We wanted to improve our understanding of what buyers of

Facebook's Ad Library API Draws Fire 2019-05-01 13:21:16Facebook has come under fire for its Ad Library API, which lets users perform customized keyword searches of all active and inactive ads related to po


Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.